Danny (00:00.046)
Have you ever wondered how to handle the tax implications of a Roth conversion without getting hit with unexpected penalties? Navigating the tax landscape can be tricky, especially when you're trying to optimize your retirement strategy. Hello, I'm Danny Goodorf, a financial planner and owner of Goodorf Financial Group, where we help individuals and families over 50 plan for a limitless retirement.

Today, we're diving deep into the critical details of paying taxes on Roth conversions. We'll break down the steps you need to take to ensure you avoid costly mistakes and make the most of this powerful retirement planning tool. If you're looking to minimize your tax burden while maximizing your financial security, you won't want to miss this episode.

Many of us have heard about the potential benefits of Roth conversions in lowering our tax burden throughout retirement. However, a common question that arises is how to properly pay the taxes on these conversions to avoid any late payment penalties. In this episode, I'll provide you with a comprehensive guide on everything you need to know about paying taxes on your Roth conversions.

ensuring that you maximize the benefits of this powerful tax strategy. As we embark on our retirement journey, it's essential to understand the significance of tax planning. Many retirees find themselves in a higher tax bracket than expected due to a combination of factors such as required minimum distributions, RMDs from traditional IRAs.

and 401Ks, Social Security benefits, and other sources of income. This is where implementing tax saving strategies like Roth conversions can make a substantial difference in preserving your hard earned retirement savings. Roth conversions involve transferring funds from a tax deferred account, such as a traditional IRA or 401K, into a Roth IRA. By doing so, you pay taxes

Danny (02:25.61)
on the converted amount upfront, but the money grows tax -free in the Roth IRA and you can withdraw it tax -free in retirement, provided you meet certain conditions. This strategy can be particularly beneficial for those with a significant portion of their retirement savings in tax -deferred accounts, as it allows for greater tax diversification and potentially

lower tax bills in the long run. However, it's important to note that Roth conversions may not be suitable for everyone. Factors such as your current tax bracket, projected retirement income, and overall financial goals should be carefully considered before deciding to proceed with a Roth conversion. Consulting with a financial professional can help you determine whether this strategy aligns

with your unique circumstances and retirement objectives. Now that we've established the potential benefits of Roth conversions, let's delve into the crux of today's episode, paying taxes on these conversions. There are two primary methods for handling the tax implications of a Roth conversion, each with its own set of considerations. The first option is to have the taxes withheld

directly from the amount you're converting. To illustrate this method, let's use an example. Suppose you're converting $100 ,000 from your traditional IRA to a Roth IRA. When you initiate the conversion, you can choose to have the taxes withheld based on your expected tax rate for the year. To determine the appropriate withholding amount, it's crucial

to have a clear understanding of your total income for the year, as this will help you estimate your marginal tax rate at both the federal and state levels. Once you've calculated your anticipated tax rate, you can withhold that percentage from your conversion amount. Continuing with our $100 ,000 conversion example, let's assume your federal tax rate is 22 % and your state tax rate

Danny (04:49.806)
is 5%. Keep in mind that not all states have an income tax. In this scenario, you would withhold a total of 27 % or $27 ,000 from the conversion amount. As a result, while you're converting $100 ,000 from your traditional IRA, only $73 ,000 will actually be deposited into your Roth IRA. It's important to note that your AGER, Place of Significant Role,

when withholding taxes from a conversion.

If you were under the age of 591 -D, you might be subject to an additional 10 % early withdrawal penalty on the withheld tax amount. This penalty is in addition to the regular taxes you would owe on the conversion. To clarify, the 10 % early withdrawal penalty only applies to the tax withholding portion of the conversion, not the entire conversion amount. When you perform a Roth conversion,

you're essentially transferring money from one IRA to another so the funds never truly leave the IRA umbrella. As a result, your age doesn't matter when it comes to the conversion itself. However, the tax withholding is treated as a distribution from the IRA and is subject to the early withdrawal penalty if you're under 5912. Let's revisit our example to illustrate this point.

If you're under 59 .12 and withholding $27 ,000 in taxes from your $100 ,000 conversion, you would owe an additional 10 % penalty on the $27 ,000. Tax withholding. This means you would incur an extra $20 ,000 $100 ,000 in penalties on top of the taxes you already owe on the withheld amount. The second method for paying taxes on Roth conversions is more straightforward.

Danny (06:51.95)
you can simply pay the taxes using cash you have available either in your bank account or brokerage account. With this approach, the entire conversion amount is transferred from your traditional IRA to your Roth IRA, and you separately pay the associated taxes using your own funds. Returning to our $100 ,000 conversion example, if you choose to pay the taxes with cash on hand,

the full $100 ,000 would be moved from your traditional IRA to your Roth IRA. You would then pay the $27 ,000 in taxes, assuming the same tax rates as before, using your personal funds, rather than having it withheld from the conversion amount. When paying taxes on a conversion with cash, it's advisable to prepay the taxes to avoid any late payment penalties.

You can either pay the taxes in full at the time of the conversion or make estimated quarterly payments throughout the year. Paying the taxes with cash on hand offers several advantages. First, it eliminates the need to worry about the age -related early withdrawal penalty associated with tax withholding. Second, it ensures that the entire conversion amount

is invested in your Roth IRA from the outset, allowing you to maximize the tax -free growth potential of those funds. Having explored both methods for paying taxes on Roth conversions, the question remains, which approach is the most advantageous? In the vast majority of cases, paying the taxes on your Roth conversions with cash on hand proves to be the better option.

By transferring the full conversion amount from your traditional IRA to your Roth IRA, you can immediately start benefiting from the tax -free growth within the Roth account. Referring back to our $100 ,000 conversion example, if you were to withhold $27 ,000 in taxes, it's more beneficial to have that $27 ,000 growing tax -free in your Roth IRA

Danny (09:16.814)
than to have it sitting in cash or in a taxable account. While the immediate benefits may not be apparent, as your net worth remains the same regardless of whether you pay the taxes from cash or withhold them from the conversion amount. The long -term advantages of having that extra $27 ,000 compounding tax -free in your Roth IRA are significant.

Not only does this strategy boost your after -tax savings, but it also enhances your overall tax diversification. Conversely, if you choose to have the taxes withheld from the conversion amount, you essentially create a hole that you need to climb out of before you can truly reap the benefits of the Roth IRA. In our example, you would need to make up the $27 ,000 tax withholding

before you have the same $100 ,000 balance in your Roth IRA as you did in your traditional IRA. Moreover, paying the taxes on your conversions with cash or from a taxable account becomes even more crucial if you plan on executing these conversions before age 59 -12. As mentioned earlier, the early withdrawal penalty can catch many people off guard.

as they may not be aware of how the tax rules apply to tax withholdings. This penalty can significantly diminish the benefits of the Roth conversion, making it essential to avoid this pitfall by paying the taxes with personal funds. The importance of having cash available to pay taxes on Roth conversions underscores the broader need to build up a cash reserve as you approach retirement.

Having sufficient cash in the bank or after -tax assets in your brokerage account provides you with the flexibility to make strategic financial decisions, such as executing Roth conversions without being forced to withhold taxes from your IRA. Creating a thoughtful plan for where you save throughout your career becomes increasingly important as you near retirement. Diversifying

Danny (11:41.794)
your savings across different account types, such as traditional IRAs, Roth IRAs, and taxable brokerage accounts can give you more options and control over your retirement income and tax planning. Given the complexities surrounding Roth conversions and the potential tax implications, it's highly recommended to consult with a trusted financial advisor when deciding how to pay the taxes

on your conversions. A skilled professional can help you navigate the various moving parts, ensure your taxes are paid correctly, and assist you in developing a comprehensive retirement income strategy that aligns with your unique goals and circumstances. Remember, while the information provided in this episode is intended to be educational and informative,

it should not be construed as financial, legal, or tax advice. Everyone's situation is different, and what may be appropriate for one person may not be suitable for another. Working closely with a qualified financial advisor can help you make informed decisions and avoid costly mistakes as you plan for a secure and fulfilling retirement.

In today's episode, we've explored the critical topic of paying taxes on Roth conversions. We've discussed the two primary methods for handling these taxes, withholding from the conversion amount and paying with cash on hand. While both approaches have their merits, paying the taxes with personal funds generally proves to be the most advantageous. As it allows you

to maximize the tax -free growth potential of your Roth IRA and avoid potential early withdrawal penalties. As you navigate the complex landscape of retirement planning, remember that building a cash reserve and creating a diversified savings strategy can provide you with the flexibility and control needed to make the most of your retirement income. And of course,

Danny (14:05.858)
Don't hesitate to seek the guidance of a trusted financial professional to help you chart a course toward a financially secure retirement. If you would like to see how Goodorf Financial Group can help you plan for a limitless retirement, go to the show notes below and sign up for our free retirement assessment. Until next time, remember that retirement planning is a journey. And every step you take today,

can have a profound impact on your financial future. Stay proactive, stay informed, and most importantly, stay focused on your goals. I look forward to joining you again next week for another insightful discussion on navigating the path to a successful retirement. Take care.