New York Post Published
Teacher Remembers Accused Colo. Gunman. Podcast 96
Unfortunately, the Colorado theater shooter was my 5th grade student. Both the prosecution and the defense sent investigators to my home to interview me regarding him. Eventually I was subpoenaed by the state of Colorado and gave testimony in the sentencing trial – which is different from the trial to prove innocence or guilt (I will admit I did not know that)
I will not say the shooters name as I think that denigrates those he shot and murdered. I will use he and him. I believe many shooters crave media attention and media needs to diminish content about these murderers. If the victims families are willing then much should be said about them.
Iin 1998-99, the shooter lived in Castroville, Calif., a tiny town of 5,000. Since the theater shootingI’ve talked about him with more than one of his former classmates. One classmates stands out let’s call him Chris.
The shooter was well-dressed, neat, wore glasses, liked to read, and excelled in all academic areas. He had two really good friends, including Chris, both sharp like him—in fact, top of the class.
I trusted the shooter so much that when he finished his assignments, I let him and another student create a class website. Mind you, this was 1998 and our computers were primitive; we had to write lines and lines of code to do anything back then. The shooter worked on this computer independently, and he did it well.
Chris reminded me how I’d race students in the field behind the school: “Only two kids beat you in our year, and the shooter was one of them.” He continued, “Mr. Karrer, those were the best years of my school years—5th grade.”
Then a pause, and: “What do you think happened to him?”
What happened to him? The shooter had everything going for him. He lived in the wealthy part of town; I’m pretty sure both of his parents had white-collar jobs.
"James Eagan Holmes passed through my life for one year. Could I have done anything that would have led to a different outcome?"
Yet Chris, who was asking the question, had been poked in the eyes by fate. His mom died before 5th grade, but he kept up with school and plugged away. He was, and still is, a sweet, lovable, biggish kid.
His dad was a Vietnam vet who worked day and night at their restaurant to make ends meet. The dad confided in me a few years ago that he had cancer, but “cancer isn’t mean enough to get me.” And he beat it: He’s still plugged away at that restaurant for many more years six years later.
So in the end, Chris turned out A-OK . . . and Jimmy didn’t.
“How can we know?” I answered Chris. “Perhaps he became psychotic. It shows up in people in their 20s. Maybe he used wicked sanity-eating drugs like OxyContin, meth, crack, and it destroyed his mind. I don’t know.
“Perhaps he just turned to the dark side? I don’t know . . . don’t know.”
I do know a few things, though. James (Jimmy) Eagan Holmes, by all accounts, has committed a brutal, evil, and, it seems, very premeditated, horrible act.
Some people snap. They’ll commit crimes of passion, commit dark acts under the influence of drugs, anger, lust, misperception, racism, ignorance, and poor or wrong decision making.
I think as a civilized society all we can do is try to minimize the impact these individuals have upon us. No civilian should have or own a military-style weapon. No civilian should be able to purchase body armor. I say this as a gun owner.
As an educator, I’d add that we desperately need nurses, psychologists, and social workers in our elementary schools. In this era of No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top, too often they aren’t even on the radar. Testing supersedes all.
Finally, I wonder: James Eagan Holmes passed through my life for one year. Could I have done anything that would have led to a different outcome? Probably not.
But I also fear that in schools somewhere out there, more kids like my mass shooter festering.
To the people of Aurora, I’m very, very, very sorry.
And to Chris, I’m so proud of you and your dad.
A version of this essay first appeared in the New York Post on July 25. Paul Karrer is a 5th grade teacher at Castroville Elementary School in north Monterey County, Calif. He is a union negotiator and was the League of United Latin American Citizens’ 2009 teacher of the year for north Monterey County.