Have you ever wondered how the smallest of similarities can link unsolved crimes together? This week, we pull back the curtain on a chilling saga of the 1996 disappearance of 16-year-old Sofia Silva and the 1997 horrific double murder of Kristin and Kati Lisk. Join us as we weave through a labyrinth of facts and suspects, including an initial lead whose innocence was secured by evidence, leading to the formation of a dedicated task force. With the striking similarities between these cases, we journey into the heart of the investigation, scrutinizing the intricate threads that hint at a shared perpetrator.
But there's more, as we shift gears from the murky depths of unsolved crimes to the inspiring resilience of a survivor. Meet Kara Robinson, a brave woman who transformed her traumatic past into a beacon of hope for others. Learn about her remarkable escape from captivity, her advocacy work for trauma survivors, and her collaboration with Elizabeth Smart for a powerful documentary. So, brace yourselves for a rollercoaster ride through the darkest corners of humanity to the indomitable spirit of survival.
Have you ever wondered how the smallest of similarities can link unsolved crimes together? This week, we pull back the curtain on a chilling saga of the 1996 disappearance of 16-year-old Sofia Silva and the 1997 horrific double murder of Kristin and Kati Lisk. Join us as we weave through a labyrinth of facts and suspects, including an initial lead whose innocence was secured by evidence, leading to the formation of a dedicated task force. With the striking similarities between these cases, we journey into the heart of the investigation, scrutinizing the intricate threads that hint at a shared perpetrator.
But there's more, as we shift gears from the murky depths of unsolved crimes to the inspiring resilience of a survivor. Meet Kara Robinson, a brave woman who transformed her traumatic past into a beacon of hope for others. Learn about her remarkable escape from captivity, her advocacy work for trauma survivors, and her collaboration with Elizabeth Smart for a powerful documentary. So, brace yourselves for a rollercoaster ride through the darkest corners of humanity to the indomitable spirit of survival.
Welcome back on my fellow crime connoisseurs. I'm your host, grace D. I really hope you guys enjoyed last week's episode about William Chester Miner. When I was researching cases to cover for the episodes and I stumbled upon that one. I found it very interesting and thought you guys might as well, so I really hope you enjoyed it. Today's case is one that spanned over several years and police believe there may even be more victims who are unidentified to this day. Trigger warning this episode contains content of sexual assault and harm to minors. This is the case of Sophia Silva, kristen and Katie Lisk and Kara Robinson.
Speaker 1:
On Monday, september 9th 1996, 16-year-old Sophia Silva and her older sister, pam, who was 21, were alone at their Spotsylvania Virginia home. Sophia decided to do her schoolwork on the front porch while enjoying a can of soda. Pam stayed inside and went about her own business. Later on Pam called out for Sophia, but she didn't get a response. Pam never heard anything while she was inside, so she figured she would walk out onto the porch and get Sophia's attention, since she wasn't responding to her. When Pam walked outside she found an open can of grape soda and Sophia's school notes, but no Sophia. As her anxiety grew and she became more worried about her sister. Pam called her parents immediately and they quickly contacted the police to report Sophia missing.
Speaker 1:
The police initially treated her case as a missing person, assuming she had just taken off, and were hopeful about Sophia's safe return in a few days. The Silva family insisted that Sophia was a happy, well-adjusted kid who would never run away. The authorities organized search parties and scoured the local areas looking for Sophia. They even used canine search dogs, searching high and low, leaving no stone unturned. Yet there was nothing in regard to finding Sophia. For about a month groups of volunteers and authorities searched for her. The police chased down several leads and even received reports of Sophia sightings. These reports came in during the weeks following her disappearance. From all over the country, from the local mall to the Las Vegas casinos. Psychics reported visions of farmhouses, cornfields and cars. According to Diane Fanning's book Into the Water about this case, one psychic reported seeing Sophia in a body of water surrounded by vegetation. With each passing day, sophia's family feared the worst. Five weeks after Sophia's disappearance, a decomposing corpse was discovered wrapped in a blanket and floating in a stream near state Route 3. Sadly, the Silva family's fears became a reality when the body was confirmed to be Sophia and to make it worse, the medical examiner confirmed that Sophia was murdered a few days before her body was discovered. The autopsy report revealed that she was sexually abused and that the cause of death was strangulation.
Speaker 1:
At the beginning of the investigation, police believed they had a breakthrough when they interviewed several of Sophia's acquaintances and learned of a local man named Carl Michael Rausch, who had shown interest in Sophia. Some witnesses claim to have seen him talking to Sophia on several occasions. Carl also happened to live four houses away from the Sylvus at the time of Sophia's disappearance. While looking into Carl, police discovered he had several criminal charges, including a decent exposure. On top of that, police believed the fibers found on Sophia's body came from the suspect's vehicle and when the crime lab said it was a match, carl Rausch was arrested for Sophia's murder. However, before Carl could be put on trial, in May 1997, investigators in Spotsylvania County were faced with a double murder similar to Sophia's case. Meanwhile it was determined that the crime lab had made mistakes in the initial investigation. The evidence ended up clearing Carl of Sophia's murder and the police focused their investigation on a serial killer.
Speaker 1:
When Ron Lisk left his home on Thursday May 1, 1997,. He had no idea it would be the last time he'd ever see his daughter's, kristen, who was 15, and Catherine, who went by Katie, aged 12. When Ron returned home that day, the girls were nowhere to be found and he now faced every parent's worst fear His daughters were missing. Ron gathered a group of people to search for Kristen and Katie and they searched nearby areas for the missing girls. Unfortunately, as the hours passed by and there were no signs of the girls, ron contacted the police, reported them missing and hoped that they would be returned home safely. The police prioritized the investigation and collaborated with local volunteers to form search parties. They utilized every resource available to them in search of the sisters. As the days ticked by, the Lisk family imagined the worst.
Speaker 1:
Tragically, just five days after the girls' disappearances, on May 6, 1997, human remains were found in the South Anna River, located about 40 miles away from the Lisk family home. The bodies were soon identified as Kristen and Katie Lisk. An initial medical examiner ruled the girls had been dead for quite some time. Later, a detailed autopsy report revealed that both Kristen and Katie had been sexually assaulted before being strangled to death, just like Sophia Silva. But you see, the Lisk family had no idea that a similar kidnapping and murder had even occurred a few months before their daughters and how the cases were so closely related. You soon noticed the similarities between Sophia Silva and the Lisk sister cases as well.
Speaker 1:
The police pleaded with the public to come forward with any information they may have on either of the cases. Over the years police established that the same person killed Kristen, katie and Sophia, but with no leads nor witnesses, authorities couldn't come up with a specific suspect. In a Washington Post article published on June 13, 1997, senior homicide detectives linked evidence between the bodies of Sophia Silva and Kristen Lisk. It was determined that both girls had been shaved in similar ways before their murders and it was unusual. This gave authorities another strong indication that the three girls had all been abducted and murdered by the same person.
Speaker 1:
A task force was created to help solve these horrific murders. The Lisk Silva task force consisted of FBI agents, state police and deputies from both Spotsylvania and King George County Sheriff's departments. Robert Restler, a retired member of the FBI's Behavioral Science Unit or BSU, as our favorite group is referred to, on criminal minds any other fans out there he spoke with the Washington Post about the shaving evidence. He said quote. It's very unusual. It could be a distinct signature. It's not a positive thing, but it has to be considered. There are too many connections that make the logical and reasonable to assume that you could have a connection in these cases. End quote. Police investigated thousands and thousands of tips, conducted numerous tests on forensic evidence, recovered from the crime scenes and matched against nearly 400,000 inmates with no luck. Sophia, kristen and Katie's cases were compared with several other unsolved murders, but nothing gave investigators the breakthrough they were looking for. It would be five years before investigators would get a massive break in the case. And it came from Columbia, south Carolina.
Speaker 1:
On Monday, june 24, 2002, 15-year-old Cara Robinson was at her best friend's house. Cara and her friend wanted to go out and her friend called her mom to see if there was anything they could do before heading out. The mom said the only thing she could do was to water the plants. So Cara said that she would go out front and water the plants so that her friend could hop in the shower. While her friend was outside and Cara was watering the plants, a man in his 30s approached her handing out pamphlets. He asked her quote Are your parents home? Cara replied Well, this isn't my house, this is my friend's house. He said OK, well what about her parents? Are her parents home? Cara answered no, her mom's not home right now. End quote.
Speaker 1:
After this interaction, the man pulled a gun and put it to her neck. He took her to the back seat of the driver's side and forced her into a large rubber-made storage bin inside his trans-am. Even though scared, cara tried keeping track of as many details as possible to increase her chances of escape and survival. From the number of turns to how he was listening to a classic rock station and smoking marble-red cigarettes. Cara memorized it all. She even memorized the serial number of the storage bin and made sure to know it by heart. Before entering the apartment, the man restrained and gagged Cara. He then took her inside and held her captive.
Speaker 1:
Over the next 18 hours Cara was drugged and sexually assaulted, her body kicked into survival mode. She continued to memorize as much as possible, from the magnets on his fridge to the names of his doctors. She even recalled seeing a hairbrush with long red hair on it, so she knew a woman lived there and there were small animals like a gerbil. She even tried manipulating her captor by asking him if she could help him in any way, and she ended up sweeping the kitchen. Cara did this in hopes of keeping her captor at ease.
Speaker 1:
The following day in the early morning hours, while her captor was still sleeping, cara made the decision to attempt to escape. She was able to free one hand from a pair of handcuffs that were connected to rope with her teeth, and then she was able to unclip the leather leg restraint that was attached to the foot of the bed. After freeing herself, she carefully made her way to the door and fled from the apartment. Cara saw a car in the parking lot and ran to it. In an interview with Crime Watch Daily, cara said quote, I ran out in front of the car and I waved my arms and stopped them and went to the driver and said I was just kidnapped. I just came from that apartment and I turned and I pointed to it. It was the guy in that apartment right there. So remember it. They were, of course, like shocked. You know, a young girl with handcuffs dangling just ran out in front of their car end quote.
Speaker 1:
When they arrived at the Richland County Sheriff's Office, cara told them about the abduction and the horrors she endured at the hands of her captor. She even still had the handcuffs dangling from her refs. They asked Cara if she could take them back to the apartment that she was being held at, and she could. Thanks to her observation skills, she was able to take the police to the apartment. A maintenance man helped police identify the residents and Cara was able to identify her abductor. The man's name was Richard Avonitz. Unfortunately, by the time they arrived, the police and Cara learned that Avonitz had fled. While searching the apartment, investigators found a footlocker containing news articles about the unsolved cases of Sophia, kristen and Katie. The Spotsylvania cases had been unsolved for years with little to go on, but the findings in South Carolina quickly linked to Avonitz.
Speaker 1:
It became clear that when Avonitz woke up to find Cara gone, he knew it was only a matter of time before the police arrived. So he took off. He ended up fleeing to Sarasota, florida. While on the lam, avonitz called his sister and started confessing to the crimes he had committed. He told his sister he had killed someone and committed more crimes than he can remember.
Speaker 1:
On June 27, 2002, police tracked Avonitz down in Sarasota where he led them on a high speed chase. The chase came to an end when he ran over a set of spike strips. The police had Ivanovich surrounded near the waterfront. They urged him to surrender peacefully, but he had a pistol in his hand. It was clear that Ivanovich had no intentions of surrendering and the police released a canine on him. He was bitten several times before turning the gun on himself and taking his own life Six days later.
Speaker 1:
On July 3, 2002, major Howard Smith of the Spotsylvania County Sheriff's Department told the press that law enforcement officials spent three hours searching the house where Ivonets lived in Spotsylvania during 1996 through 1997, and that other homes in the area where he lived will also be searched. Major Smith also said that detectives found evidence in their South Carolina searches that Ivonets was stalking other girls in Spotsylvania. Police discovered notes about the three girls who were murdered and another unsolved case of Alicia Reynolds in 1996 in Culpeper, virginia. The footlocker had contained a note with handwritten directions to the dump site of Alicia's body. Major Smith told the Washington Post quote obviously we're all anxious and want to solve this, but we're also very cautious. We're going to take our time. We don't want to rush things. We don't know if this is our guy. This is the best lead we've had out of 12,000 leads to come out. End quote. In late August, forensic tests confirmed that Ivonets had murdered Sophia, kristen and Katie. Fibers from Ivonets' apartment matched the ones found on the girls' bodies. They even found finger and palm prints belonging to Kristen Lisk inside the trunk of Ivonets' car from five years prior. Dna samples were also a match. This gave the authorities the concrete evidence they needed to prove that Richard Ivonets was responsible for the abductions, rapes and murders of Sophia Silva in 1996 and Kristen Lisk and Katie Lisk in 1997. Based on the evidence found in Ivonets' apartment, investigators determined that had Kara not been able to escape, she would have had the same untimely death as the other three girls.
Speaker 1:
As investigators learned more about Ivonets, it was uncovered that he was a Navy veteran who received a good conduct medal during his service and he was honorably discharged after serving eight years as a sonar technician. However, in 1987, while still in the Navy, ivonets committed his first known sexual crime. In January 1987, ivonets exposed himself and masturbated in front of a 15-year-old girl and her three-year-old sister in Orange Park, florida. A month later, when his ship returned to port, ivonets was arrested and sentenced to three years of probation. According to the Washington Post, police records say he confessed both orally and written to his guilt. The report stated quote Suspect stated he has a problem with masturbating in front of girls. When he feels the urge, he drives around looking for a girl 18 or 19 years old, short in height and has brunette hair. End quote. And it blows my mind that with an arrest and a sentence of three years probation for this crime. And he was still honorably discharged when this happened while he was in the Navy and was arrested after his ship got back to port.
Speaker 1:
Sophia Silva was a brilliant student and a lively teen. She was described as kindhearted, the light of her parents' lives, a down-to-earth girl and never hesitated to help those in need. Sophia was known for making friends quickly and was popular in her community. She had big plans for her future and she couldn't wait to graduate high school. Kristen and Katie Lisk lived on Blockhouse Road in Spotsylvania County, virginia, with their parents. The girls shared an intimate bond and were extremely close. They had an excellent relationship with their parents. Those who knew them said that the two were always ready to help others and make new friends. Like more kids their age, they loved hanging out with their friends and had great hopes for their futures.
Speaker 1:
When Cara learned of Ivana's suicide, she was disappointed. In an interview with America's Most Wanted she said quote I wanted to go on trial and let him see me again and know I was his downfall. I wanted him to look at me and know that choosing me was the biggest mistake he ever made. End ofANKLIMAGENIきづかけたでした. Thank you for watching. Because of Kara's escape and ability to memorize details in her case and lead police back to the apartment, sophia, kristen and Katie's cases were all able to be closed. A $150,000 reward was offered for solving the murders, and the reward was granted to Kara. Thanks to her bravery.
Speaker 1:
Despite the tragedy, kara Robinson remained strong and has consistently advocated for policies and reforms that will help people in similar situations. Kara had been through hell and she was beginning her healing journey. In an interview with Crime Watch Daily, richland County Sheriff Leon Lott said quote shortly after her kidnapping, I met with her and her family in my office. She was a survivor and she was a fighter and she was a warrior and she wasn't going to be a victim. I've got daughters myself. I kind of adopted her as one of my daughters too and wanted to make sure that she continued to be that survivor. So we bonded. End quote. So when Kara was looking for a summer job, sheriff Lott had an idea. He offered Kara an administrative job at the Sheriff's Department and she started working there and continued to do so for a couple of years. Kara was studying to become a teacher in college, but she loved working at the Sheriff's Department, so she decided to murder her two passions and became a school resource officer.
Speaker 1:
While at Cadet at the police academy, kara had managed to keep her story under wraps until her cover was blown one day. She said quote I was actually in class at the academy and the instructor started teaching on my case. One of the first slides was a picture of Kristen and Katie Lisk and Sophia Silva, and I saw it and I just went, oh no. And so at the end of class I went up to her and I said I just want you to know that Kara is me. And her face just turned blood red and she was like oh my god, I'm so sorry. So at that point she then told other people in the academy leadership and they came to me and they were like we want to nominate you for an award at the academy. Then I was given an award for courage and bravery at the academy. At my graduation end quote In 2019, after participating in an interview with kidnapping survivor Elizabeth Smart, kara took part in a 90 minute lifetime special Smart Justice the Jamie Kloss case, with five other survivors to support Kloss, a Wisconsin teen who had escaped her captor in 2019.
Speaker 1:
In an interview with People magazine, kara said quote I sat down on a couch with Elizabeth and five other women who had survived kidnappings and sexual assaults, and that was the moment that I realized that I really had a bigger purpose. I knew that I could find a reason for what happened and I always knew that what happened to me was something that happened so that I could help other people. I was healed on that couch, sitting there, talking to those women in a way that I didn't even realize I was hurting, just to sit down and talk to women who really understood the heart of what I had been through. End quote Elizabeth Smart inspired Kara, an advocate for trauma survivors, to continue to speak out. The two women teamed up to work on a documentary that could do Kara's story justice.
Speaker 1:
Escaping Captivity the Cara Robinson story premiered on Oxygen in 2021. Detailing Cara not only outsmarted her captor, richard Vonitz, but used her remarkable memory to help police track him down and stop his reign of terror. Elizabeth spoke with Oxygen about the documentary and said, quote I want everyone to always have a sense of hope, because no one gets through this life without their fair share of struggle and trial and heartbreak, and I think Cara's story really just brings that ultimate sense of hope. I'm so proud of Cara and I'm so proud of everything she's doing. End quote. Lifetime made a movie about Cara's horrors of abduction, sexual assault and harrowing escape from Vonitz A Girl who Escaped. The Cara Robinson story premiered on Saturday, february 11, 2022, exclusively on Lifetime Network. It's now available to watch on Amazon and I will have it linked in the source material for you guys.
Speaker 1:
Today, cara Robinson is married to a man she met at the Sheriff's Department and has taken some time off from the Sheriff's Department to raise her two small boys. She is currently pregnant with her third child, a little girl. Cara decided the moment she was abducted and from that point on, to never be a victim. She's a survivor, she said. Quote. I think that to say you're a victim, then someone took something from you. Nothing was taken from me. I refuse to give that man that power, and that's the case of Sophia Silva, kristen Lisk, katie Lisk and Cara Robinson.
Speaker 1:
Thanks to Cara's bravery and escaping from Vonitz, sophia, kristen and Katie's cases were closed. Unfortunately, alicia's case is still unsolved. Police have fingerprints and hairs that they believe belong to Alicia's killer, but no matches have been made to date. If you or someone you know may have information into Alicia's case, please contact the Virginia State Police at 1-800-572-2260. That's 1-800-572-2260. Or contact the Bureau of Criminal Investigation at 1-888-300-0156. That's 1-888-300-0156. Be sure to follow us on Instagram at CrimeContosaurus, and fill out the case suggestion form in the link in the bio if you have a case you'd like to hear covered. In the meantime, keep it classy, conosaurus, and I'll catch you on the next case. Thanks for watching.