GIKN Global Intelligence Weekly Wrap Up for 2024 06 21
Welcome to the Global Intelligence Weekly Wrap-Up for the week ending June 21st, 2024. I'm Neil Bisson, your host, and a retired intelligence officer with the Canadian Security Intelligence Service. I am also the Director of the Global Intelligence Knowledge Network.
Each week, we break down the latest headlines, offering insights into national security, foreign interference, espionage, and terrorism.
Before we dive into today's stories, I want to emphasize how essential your support is for us to continue delivering high-quality, insightful content.
If you enjoy our podcast, please visit our website at www.globalintelligenceknowledgenetwork.com. There, you'll find a wealth of information, including articles, blogs, my media appearances, and dossiers on various intelligence agencies.
We also run a YouTube channel, Inside Intelligence GIKN, where you can explore videos on a range of intelligence topics, from Cryptocurrency and Terrorism to Situational Awareness and our multipart series on Killer Spies: The Dark Side of Intelligence. Don’t forget to subscribe to stay updated.
Additionally, I co-host another podcast called "Spies Like Us" with fellow retired CSIS intelligence professionals, Al Treddenick and Phil Gurski. We dive into current intelligence topics both within Canada and globally. It’s a fascinating listen, and I highly recommend checking it out.
Make sure to subscribe to the Global Intelligence Weekly Wrap-Up on Spotify, YouTube, Apple Podcasts, or simply ask your smart speaker to play it. If you enjoy the content, please leave a comment, give us a rating, and share it with others. Your feedback and support are vital in keeping the lights on and the information flowing.
You can also support the show by becoming a supporter at www.buzzsprout.com/2336717/support. Your contributions are greatly appreciated and help ensure we can continue bringing you these important insights.
All the links to the mentioned platforms and resources are included in the text of this podcast. Thank you for your support. Now, let’s dive into this week’s episode of Global Intelligence Weekly Wrap-Up.
MUSIC
Today, we're diving into a significant development in Canada's efforts to combat foreign interference. The topic of discussion is the recent unanimous approval of Bill C-70 by the House of Commons.
The article we're referencing is titled, "Foreign interference bill gets unanimous final passage in House of Commons." Let's start with a brief summary of this landmark legislation.
The House of Commons has unanimously passed Bill C-70, also known as the Countering Foreign Interference Act.
This comprehensive bill aims to create a foreign agent registry, expand intelligence gathering powers, and introduce new criminal offenses to address foreign interference.
From an intelligence perspective, this bill is significant. It empowers Canadian intelligence agencies like CSIS and the RCMP with enhanced tools to detect and counter foreign influence operations.
The creation of a foreign agent registry is a crucial step, as it mandates that individuals working with foreign powers must register their activities, thereby increasing transparency and accountability.
To provide some context, this legislation comes amid increasing pressure on the Liberal government to address threats to diaspora communities and Canada's electoral process.
A recent report from the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians (NSICOP) highlighted concerning allegations that some parliamentarians might be knowingly or unknowingly collaborating with foreign governments.
Additionally, an interim report by Quebec Justice Marie-Josée Hogue found that China meddled in the last two Canadian elections.
Although this interference did not alter the outcomes of the 2019 and 2021 votes, it did undermine the democratic process.
Comparing this to similar trends globally, we see that foreign interference is a growing concern for many democracies, with similar measures being implemented in countries like the U.S. and Australia.
The bill has garnered support from various political parties, with the Conservatives advocating for its fast-tracking to be in place before the next election in 2025.
However, it has faced criticism from 14 civil liberty groups, including the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, which argue that the bill is overly broad and rushed, with potential Charter issues that need addressing.
In my professional analysis, the bill is simply a first step down a long road to ensure that Canada’s democratic process maintains its integrity and that Canadians maintain a level of confidence in the system.
Bill C-70 is far from a silver bullet in combating the National Security threat of Foreign Interference, but if implemented properly will help Canadians and politicians understand and combat this issue.
To summarize, Bill C-70 represents a pivotal step in Canada's fight against foreign interference.
Its provisions aim to bolster our intelligence capabilities and protect the integrity of our democratic processes.
MUSIC
In the next story we look at how diplomacy continues despite the threat of Foreign Interference in Canada and beyond.
The news article is titled, "Canada to continue diplomacy with alleged foreign interference actors: Joly," which explores Canada’s diplomatic stance towards nations accused of meddling in its democratic institutions. Let’s dive into the details.
Foreign Affairs Minister Melanie Joly has made it clear that Canada will continue to engage in diplomacy with countries accused of foreign interference, specifically China and India.
This decision comes amid ongoing public inquiry into allegations of meddling in the 2019 and 2021 elections by these nations.
From an intelligence perspective, this approach of maintaining diplomatic channels while addressing interference threats is a double-edged sword.
On one hand, it allows for open communication and the potential to resolve issues through dialogue.
On the other hand, it requires careful balancing to ensure that Canada’s national security is not compromised in the process.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has identified China as a significant threat to Canadian democracy.
Despite this, Joly emphasizes the importance of diplomacy as a means to convey difficult messages and reduce tensions.
To provide some background, the urgency of this issue has been underscored by the recent NSICOP report that alleged some Canadian parliamentarians may be collaborating with foreign governments, knowingly or otherwise.
This report has added fuel to the ongoing inquiry into foreign interference, particularly focusing on China and India.
Historically, Canada’s diplomatic relations with China have been strained, especially following the expulsion of Zhao Wei, the former Chinese consul general in Toronto, who was accused of intimidating a Canadian MP.
With India, the situation is further complicated by allegations that agents of Prime Minister Modi’s government were involved in the murder of Sikh leader Hardeep Singh Nijjar in British Columbia.
Minister Joly has pointed to several actions that demonstrate Canada’s firm stance against foreign interference.
These include the expulsion of Chinese diplomats and continued engagement with India despite serious allegations.
She also highlighted the necessity of diplomacy in addressing these complex issues, arguing that it is the best way to manage tensions and convey difficult messages.
From my professional viewpoint, while diplomacy is crucial, it must be complemented by robust counter-intelligence measures to safeguard national security.
The balance between engaging with foreign powers and protecting democratic institutions is delicate and requires continuous, vigilant effort.
To summarize, Canada’s decision to continue diplomatic engagement with nations accused of interference, like China and India, underscores the complexity of modern international relations.
While diplomacy is essential, it must be part of a broader strategy that includes strong intelligence and security measures.
Looking forward, we can expect Canada to deepen its relationships with other critical partners in the Indo-Pacific region, which will be vital for maintaining a balanced and secure foreign policy.
Canada’s foreign policy focus on countries outside of India and China will allow for a more leveraged position on the world stage and demonstrate that Canada takes the threat of Foreign Interference seriously.
This does not mean that the current diplomatic back channels with India and China should be discarded.
In fact its just the opposite. By maintaining political diplomatic communication with China and India, Canada has a better understanding of what their intentions are and can gauge if they are truly working to improve the international relationship, or simply providing face time to Canadian politicians and embassy staff.
MUSIC
Sticking with Foreign Interference in the Government, we dive into yet another crucial and often overlooked aspect of foreign interference – financial meddling.
Information provided from a recent opinion article entitled "Why is the Hogue Commission overlooking foreign meddling through the financial system?" from The Globe and Mail.
Let’s find out why the Foreign Interference Commission needs to follow the money and how this impacts our national security.
Foreign interference is a topic that continues to dominate headlines, and rightfully so.
Recently, allegations have emerged that some of our parliamentarians may have accepted money and perks from foreign actors, notably from China and India.
The big question on everyone's mind: why isn’t the Hogue Commission looking into financial meddling more closely?
The article outlines alarming revelations from the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians (NSICOP) and the initial report from the Hogue Commission. Both documents suggest that foreign interference through financial systems is a significant threat that hasn't been sufficiently addressed.
From an intelligence perspective, financial transactions often provide the most concrete evidence of foreign interference.
Money trails can expose the who, where, and how of foreign influence operations.
If the Canadian Intelligence Community and Canada’s national law enforcement follow the money, we can identify and disrupt these operations more effectively.
Let’s put this into context. History has shown us that financial flows are integral to foreign interference.
Just look at examples from France, where Marine Le Pen's far-right party received substantial loans from a Russian bank.
Similar cases have been reported in Italy and the UK. These instances illustrate how financial meddling can influence political landscapes and elections.
In Canada, the allegations are equally troubling.
Reports indicate that funds from foreign entities were funneled through intermediaries to support political candidates.
These financial operations were often disguised to conceal their origins, making them difficult to trace without proper resources and oversight.
The article quotes NSICOP's findings, revealing that some parliamentarians may have accepted funds knowingly or through willful blindness.
This is a damning accusation that warrants immediate and thorough investigation.
From my professional experience, remuneration is one of the primary motivations for foreign operatives.
The lack of adequate funding for departments tasked with investigating these issues hampers our ability to combat this threat effectively.
We need to allocate more resources to financial intelligence units like the Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada (FinTRAC) and the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI).
To sum up, the Hogue Commission must expand its mandate to include a thorough investigation into financial meddling.
Understanding and tracking financial transactions related to foreign interference is crucial for safeguarding our democratic institutions.
The government’s reaction to these findings will be telling.
Will they bolster the resources of national security departments, or will they continue to overlook this critical issue?
Only time will tell, but we must remain vigilant and demand transparency and accountability.
MUSIC
In this next article from the CBC, we look at a significant topic making waves in Canadian politics: Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's recent comments on the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians (NSICOP) report and its implications.
This was covered by a CBC News article titled, "Trudeau says Canadians should be 'wary' of leaders who say foreign interference hasn't touched their teams."
Let’s start with a summary of the article.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, in an exclusive interview with CBC’s Power & Politics, suggested that Canadians should be cautious of political leaders who claim their parties are untouched by foreign interference.
This comment seems to be directed at NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh, who after reading the classified, unredacted NSICOP report, assured reporters that his party was not compromised.
The NSICOP report, which is central to this discussion, revealed that some parliamentarians were "witting" or "semi-witting" participants in foreign interference efforts.
Trudeau emphasized the need for thorough processes before making accusations, suggesting that interference crosses party lines and is multifaceted.
From an intelligence perspective, Trudeau's cautious approach underscores the delicate balance between transparency and operational security.
Intelligence collection methods and the safety of sources are paramount.
Revealing specific names without proper vetting could jeopardize ongoing operations and the integrity of our intelligence apparatus.
This situation isn't unprecedented. Historically, intelligence agencies worldwide have grappled with the challenge of informing the public while protecting sensitive methods.
Comparing this to similar incidents, such as the Cold War espionage cases, we see a consistent theme: the need for discretion in intelligence matters to ensure long-term national security.
The article highlights varied reactions from political leaders:
- Jagmeet Singh expressed heightened concern and accused Trudeau of prioritizing party protection over national security.
- Elizabeth May from the Green Party felt reassured by the report, emphasizing the need to avoid a "witch hunt" atmosphere.
- Pierre Poilievre from the Conservative Party called for the public naming of implicated parliamentarians, leveraging parliamentary privilege as a safeguard. Trudeau and his Public Safety Minister rejected this, citing national security risks.
From the perspective of a retired intelligence professional, Trudeau's stance could be considered reflective of a strategic approach to protect intelligence sources and maintain operational integrity.
While transparency is crucial, it must be balanced against the potential risks to national security.
To summarize, Trudeau’s comments and the NSICOP report highlight the complex nature of foreign interference in Canadian politics.
The varied reactions from political leaders illustrate the delicate balance between transparency, political accountability, and national security.
Looking ahead, we should expect continued scrutiny and debate over how to handle such sensitive information.
The ongoing public inquiry led by Commissioner Marie-Josée Hogue will be critical in providing clarity and direction.
MUSIC
Our next article is from Reuters titled "Russia buying spies to make up for expelled diplomats, German security agency says."
The article reports that Russia has been ramping up its efforts to recruit German citizens as spies.
This move comes as a direct response to the expulsion of approximately 600 Russian diplomats from Europe, a measure taken to curb Moscow's intelligence operations following its invasion of Ukraine.
The German Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, or BfV, has highlighted that Russia is employing blackmail and substantial financial incentives to secure German informants.
Two German nationals, charged with high treason last August, reportedly received around 400,000 euros each for their espionage activities.
From an intelligence perspective, this illustrates a significant shift in Russian espionage strategy.
With reduced diplomatic cover, Russian intelligence agencies are now forced to rely more heavily on local assets. This not only increases operational risks but also underscores Russia's adaptability and resourcefulness in sustaining its intelligence operations abroad.
Historically, Russia has maintained an extensive network of spies within Europe, often under diplomatic cover.
The expulsion of 600 diplomats represents a substantial blow to their operational capabilities.
However, the BfV's report indicates that Russian intelligence services are compensating for this loss by leveraging financial resources and coercive tactics to recruit new agents within Germany.
This situation parallels other recent intelligence operations where countries have had to adapt to increased scrutiny and restrictions. For instance, after the Skripal poisoning in the UK, there was a notable increase in covert Russian activities in other European countries.
Thomas Haldenwang, the president of the BfV, has been vocal about the ongoing threats posed by Russian intelligence.
At a recent press conference, Haldenwang emphasized the financial depth of Russian espionage operations, noting that substantial agent fees highlight Moscow's continued commitment to its intelligence goals.
From my professional standpoint, this development is alarming but not unexpected.
The aggressive recruitment techniques, particularly targeting Germans with ties to Russia, indicate a well-resourced and determined adversary.
The broader implications for national security are profound, as these efforts can lead to significant breaches of sensitive information and potentially destabilizing activities within Germany.
To sum up, Russia's increased reliance on local spies following the expulsion of its diplomats underscores the evolving nature of global intelligence operations.
As Western nations, including NATO, step up their counter-espionage measures, it's crucial for individuals and institutions to remain vigilant and informed about these persistent threats.
Looking ahead, we can expect Russia to continue exploring innovative methods to circumvent restrictions and maintain its intelligence presence in Europe.
Staying updated on these developments is key to understanding and countering such espionage activities.
MUSIC
The next article we're discussing is titled, 'Canada’s senate passes foreign interference bill, now awaits royal assent' from National News."
"The Senate has just passed a pivotal government bill aimed at deterring, investigating, and punishing foreign interference.
This bill is now awaiting royal assent, and it could have significant implications for our national security landscape. Let's break down what this means."
"The bill, approved late Wednesday, introduces criminal provisions against deceptive or surreptitious acts related to foreign interference.
It also facilitates the sharing of sensitive information with businesses and establishes a foreign influence transparency registry.
This registry would require certain individuals to register with the federal government to help guard against foreign meddling."
"From an intelligence perspective, this legislation is a critical step forward. Foreign interference isn't just a theoretical threat—it's a reality that many nations face today.
By criminalizing deceptive acts and enhancing information-sharing capabilities, Canada is fortifying its defenses against such threats."
"But this bill isn't without controversy. Senators voted down an amendment aimed at ensuring innocent people are not wrongly implicated.
Civil society groups have also voiced concerns, arguing that the rush to pass the bill—introduced less than seven weeks ago—could result in flawed provisions that might violate individual rights."
"To provide some context, foreign interference often involves states and foreign entities employing individuals to advance their political goals without disclosing their affiliations.
This kind of covert activity can undermine democratic processes and national security. Similar measures have been implemented in other countries, such as the United States' Foreign Agents Registration Act (FARA), which has been used to track and limit foreign influence."
"This isn't the first time Canada has had to address foreign meddling.
There have been growing concerns about alleged interference in Canada's Parliament and other democratic institutions. This new bill aims to tackle these issues head-on by increasing transparency and accountability."
"Experts have mixed views on this legislation.
Some argue that the transparency registry is a necessary tool to combat foreign influence.
Others, however, worry about the potential for overreach and the impact on civil liberties. These are valid concerns that need to be carefully considered as the bill moves forward."
"Drawing from my experience, I believe this legislation is a step in the right direction, but it must be implemented with caution. The balance between national security and individual rights is delicate and requires ongoing scrutiny."
"To wrap up, Canada's new bill on foreign interference represents a significant development in the fight against covert foreign influence.
While it strengthens our national security framework, it's essential to remain vigilant about its implementation to avoid unintended consequences."
MUSIC
In this next article we are discussing a significant development in Canada’s approach to counter-terrorism.
Our topic is drawn from an article titled, 'Canada lists Iran Revolutionary Guards as ‘terrorist’ group' from Al Jazeera."
On Wednesday, Canada officially listed Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) as a 'terrorist' entity.
This move aims to counter terrorist financing and sends a strong message about Canada’s stance against Iran’s unlawful actions and support for terrorism.
"The decision to list the IRGC through the Criminal Code listing regime is a crucial step in Canada’s broader efforts to combat terrorism.
The IRGC has long been associated with terrorist entities such as Hezbollah and Hamas.
This listing requires Canadian financial institutions to freeze any IRGC assets and prohibits Canadian citizens from engaging in financial dealings with the group."
"From an intelligence perspective, this designation is significant. It underscores the IRGC's role in destabilizing activities and human rights abuses.
By targeting the financial networks supporting these activities, Canada aims to disrupt the IRGC’s operations and limit its influence."
"Iran has condemned this move as politically motivated and has stated that it will not affect the Revolutionary Guards' power.
However, the international community, particularly countries like the United States which designated the IRGC as a terrorist group in 2019, supports this approach."
"To provide some background, the IRGC is an elite branch of Iran’s military, operating with considerable autonomy and answering directly to Iran’s Supreme Leader.
Relations between Iran and Canada have been strained for decades, especially after Ottawa cut diplomatic ties in 2012 due to Iran’s nuclear program and support for the Syrian government."
"This relationship further deteriorated in 2020 after the IRGC shot down a plane carrying dozens of Canadian citizens and residents.
This tragic incident highlighted the risks posed by the IRGC and added urgency to Canada’s counter-terrorism efforts."
"Dominic LeBlanc, Canada’s minister of public safety, cited Iran’s human rights record and its destabilizing actions as key reasons for the decision.
He emphasized that this move builds on Canada’s broader efforts to hold Iran accountable for its support of terrorism."
"Foreign Minister Melanie Joly also urged Canadians not to travel to Iran, citing a heightened risk of arbitrary detention.
This is a clear indication of the serious nature of the threat posed by the IRGC and the broader Iranian regime."
"To summarize, Canada’s designation of the IRGC as a terrorist entity is a pivotal step in its fight against terrorism and its efforts to hold Iran accountable for its actions.
This move aligns with international efforts and sends a strong message about Canada’s commitment to countering terrorist activities."
"In the future, we can expect increased scrutiny on financial transactions and further measures to counteract the IRGC’s influence.
It’s essential to stay informed and vigilant as these developments unfold.
MUSIC
That's a wrap for this week's episode of Global Intelligence Weekly Wrap-Up. Before we sign off, here are a few ways to stay connected and support our mission.
Be sure to visit our website, globalintelligenceknowledgenetwork.com. It's packed with valuable resources, including insights, terminology, my media appearances, and dossiers on both foreign and domestic intelligence agencies. You'll also find a treasure trove of articles and blogs that dive deep into the intelligence world.
Don't miss our YouTube channel, Inside Intelligence GIKN @InsideIntelligenceGIKN. There, you can watch videos covering a range of topics like Cryptocurrency and Terrorism, Situational Awareness, Ghouling, and our latest multipart series, Killer Spies: The Dark Side of Intelligence. There's plenty of great content waiting for you.
I'm also the co-host of another podcast, "Spies Like Us," with retired CSIS intelligence professionals Al Treddenick and Phil Gurski. We explore current issues in the intelligence environment both in Canada and internationally. It's a fascinating listen that I highly recommend.
Make sure to subscribe to the Global Intelligence Weekly Wrap-Up. You can find us on Spotify, YouTube, Apple Podcasts, or simply ask your smart speaker to play it. If you enjoyed today's episode, please leave a comment and share your thoughts.
Lastly, if you'd like to support the show and help us continue delivering this content, consider becoming a supporter at buzzsprout.com/2336717/support. Your contributions make a significant difference and help keep the lights on and the information flowing.
Thank you for joining me this week. As always, stay curious, stay informed, and stay safe. See you next time on Global Intelligence Weekly Wrap-Up.