The Haunting Case of Shannon Hercutt

What if a simple family vacation turned into a nightmare that unraveled dark secrets and suspicions? In this gripping episode of Crime Tapes, I'm Nessa, and we uncover the haunting details surrounding Shannon Hercutt's mysterious death in 2009. From the chilling discovery of her Cadillac Escalade off a cliff in Tennessee to the bombshell revelation from the autopsy that her fatal injuries came from blunt force trauma, not the crash itself, this case is shrouded in intrigue and unanswered questions. We dive deep into Penny Stevens' relentless pursuit of justice, her heartbreaking realization during a family vacation, and her unwavering belief that their father, Ted Hercutt, was involved in Shannon's tragic end.

Join us as we explore Penny's bold public accusations on the Dr. Phil show in 2015, where she directly implicated Ted in Shannon's death, sparking nationwide interest and controversy. Despite Ted's vehement denials and his subsequent death in 2017, the case refused to fade into obscurity. In a twist of fate, the Sevier County Sheriff's Office reopened the investigation in 2024, renewing hope for justice and offering a $45,000 reward for information leading to an arrest. Tune in for a spine-chilling journey that highlights the lengths a sister will go to uncover the truth and the enduring impact of a family's darkest hour. Stay safe, stay curious, and don't forget to subscribe and review to support our mission in bringing these compelling stories to light.

Transcript

Speaker 1: 0:00

Welcome to the Crime Tapes. I'm Nessa, and today we delve into a case that starts on August 4, 2009, with a tragic event that would unravel a web of suspicion and family tension. Penny Stevens was vacationing with her daughter, her father, ted Hercutt and his wife in Myrtle Beach, south Carolina. While Penny was collecting shells along the shore a favorite pastime of her younger sister, shannon Hercutt, her daughter spotted them from the hotel balcony. Distressed, she called out that her grandfather was crying and something was terribly wrong. Rushing back to the hotel, penny was devastated to hear from her father that Shannon had died. Shannon's Cadillac Escalade had been found off a cliff on Walker Trail Road behind Dollywood in Tennessee. The crash had occurred late on August 3rd and had triggered an OnStar alert. Emergency responders faced dark and challenging conditions as they arrived at the scene, but an autopsy later revealed that Shannon had died from blunt force trauma, not from the crash itself.

Speaker 1: 1:03

As Penny and her family returned to Tennessee, her suspicions about her father grew stronger. Ted's behavior, including his focus on the financial implications of Shannon's death and his strained relationship with his children, raised red flags. Penny felt an eerie certainty that Ted was involved, driven by the fact that Shannon had recently removed him from her will. Penny's fears were compounded when she noticed Ted's peculiar behavior, such as his insistence on providing an alibi by taking a photograph of the family on the hotel balcony. This odd request only deepened her suspicions. Determined to seek justice, penny appeared on the Dr Phil show in February 2015,. Justice Penny appeared on the Dr Phil show in February 2015, publicly accusing Ted of orchestrating Shannon's murder for financial gain. Despite Ted's denial and his attempts to shift blame, penny's conviction remained firm. She believed that Ted's motive was rooted in the financial benefits he lost due to his exclusion from Shannon's will.

Speaker 1: 2:01

The investigation into Shannon's death continued even after Ted's passing in November 2017. In 2024, the Sevier County Sheriff's Office reopened the case and resubmitted evidence for further testing. Keeping the investigation active, a $45,000 reward is offered for information leading to an arrest. If you have any details about the case, please contact the Sevier County Sheriff's Office at 865-453-4668. Thank you for joining us on this journey into the unknown. If you enjoyed today's episode, please subscribe to the Crime Tapes and leave us a review. Your support helps us bring these stories to light. Until next time, stay safe and stay curious.