Murder Phone

Episode 5 “The T- Shirt and The Tooth”

Tony Ciaglia Season 5 Episode 5

Metheny sends Tony an unexpected present. He also describes more about his first kill experiences.

  • Joe Metheny sends Tony a tooth that he pulled out of his mouth. This tooth actually consumed human flesh.
  • Metheny also provides Tony with a T Shirt that is a 9 Large which give you an idea of the size of this monster.  I
  • On the T-Shirt Tiny depicts in cartoon form what he used to do to his victims as he prepared them to serve at his BBQ stand. 
  • Al and Tony show and describe both the Tooth and T- shirt on the show. You can see them both on the You Tube channel or Buy Me a Coffee. 
  • Metheny actually admits to losing his virginity to a German Shepard named Sheena. 
  • Given the dark and disgusting nature of these subjects Tony and Al add a lot of humor to try and lighten the mood. 


Standard Legal Disclaimer for Murder Phone:

“The content of this podcast, including all phone calls, interviews, and original commentary, is the exclusive property of Murder Phone Podcasts, You Tube Video,Ciaglia Productions and Murder Phone LLC and any and all Murder Phone Productions. Unauthorized use, reproduction, or redistribution of any part of this show—including but not limited to recorded calls with incarcerated individuals—is strictly prohibited and may result in legal action.

All audio recordings featured in this podcast are used with permission and are protected under copyright law. Any individual or entity using our original material without express written consent will be subject to copyright infringement claims and DMCA takedown notices.

Murder Phone is more than a podcast—it’s a protected body of work. Respect it, or face the consequences.”