Episode 417: "A Conversation with Eugene Peterson"

Restoring the Soul with Michael John Cusick

Chapters
0:00
— Michael's Introduction: Why This Conversation, Why Now
5:30
— Why Eric Peterson Reads His Father's Words
7:10
— Introduction to Eugene Peterson (1995)
8:41
— What Is Spiritual Theology?
10:04
— The Resurgence of Spirituality and Spiritual Direction
11:11
— Has Counseling's Failure Made Room for Formation?
12:11
— What Holiness Actually Is
13:03
— Holiness as Energetic, Not Claustrophobic
13:14
— The Loss of Trinitarian Wholeness
15:33
— Can We Recover What's Been Lost?
16:12
— Regent College: The Unseminary
18:00
— Why Students Should Read Novels and Poetry
18:50
— Existence Has a Story Shape
19:45
— Are You a Narrative Theologian?
20:11
— The Arts and the Christian Imagination
20:51
— The Chrysostom Society
22:50
— Words as Carriers of Spirit
23:51
— When Language Becomes Functionalized
25:17
— Intentionality vs. Spontaneity with Words
26:15
— A Life of Prayer vs. Saying Your Prayers
28:48
— Dr. Follett in the Hammock: "I Haven't Prayed in Forty Years"
30:18
— How The Message Came to Be
32:36
— The Harvest of a Lifetime of Pastoring
33:48
— Growing Up in a Butcher Shop — and Why It Mattered
36:37
— One of the Devil's Finest Pieces of Work
37:21
— The Bible Is Given to Us to Be Lived
38:53
— Disaffected Outsiders and Bored Insiders
40:42
— Translating the Old Testament — and Song of Songs
41:56
— Plans for The Complete Message Bible
43:40
— The Humility of Always Coming in Second
44:24
— The Weight of Becoming Known
46:41
— On Criticism and a Dear Letter from an 87-Year-Old
47:40
— Poetry and the Arts as Subversive
49:03
— Jesus Was a Master of Indirection
49:39
— Every Time Someone Tells a Story Well, the Gospel Is Served
51:25
— Evangelism: Bullying vs. Good News
53:36
— Depersonalization and the Incarnation
54:40
— Stop Charging Into the Fray — Working from Grace, Not Anxiety
54:54
— What Eugene Peterson Wants to Be Remembered For
55:32
— If You Were Giving Your Last Sermon
Restoring the Soul with Michael John Cusick
Episode 417: "A Conversation with Eugene Peterson"
Sep 21, 2026 Season 17 Episode 417
Michael John Cusick

In 1995, Michael sat down with Eugene Peterson for a conversation that was published in the Mars Hill Review and later in Eugene's own book Subversive Spirituality. There were no podcasts then. No one could have imagined that someday a person driving to work or sitting alone at home could put on headphones and hear a conversation recorded decades earlier. Eugene believed words were never merely information — they carried presence, they revealed, they deepened intimacy. So Michael began to wonder: what if this conversation could have a voice? And then a better possibility emerged. What if Eugene's words could be read by his son?

The voice you hear speaking Eugene Peterson's words belongs to Eugene's son, Eric Peterson, who recently retired after twenty-nine years of pastoral ministry of his own.

In the conversation, Eugene talks about why he's suspicious of Bible studies, what it means to live a life of prayer rather than merely say your prayers, why poets and novelists are the church's most important allies, and what it looks like to stop working from anxiety and start working from grace. At the end, Michael asks what Eugene wants to be remembered for. He laughs at the question, says it isn't a good one, and then answers it.

Support the show


ENGAGE THE RESTORING THE SOUL PODCAST:
- Follow us on YouTube
- Tweet us at @michaeljcusick and @PodcastRTS
- Like us on Facebook
- Follow us on Instagram & Twitter
- Follow Michael on Twitter
- Email us at info@restoringthesoul.com 

Thanks for listening!

Episode Artwork Episode 417: "A Conversation with Eugene Peterson" 57:02 Episode Artwork Episode 416: Dr. Alison Cook, "A Part of Me Doesn't Like God Very Much" 36:17 Episode Artwork Episode 415: Restoring the Soul Weekend, "Healing for Men In 66 Hours" 39:11 Episode Artwork Episode 414: SOUL CARE SUMMER - Dr. Jim Wilder, "Attachment Is How God Communicates Now" 54:56 Episode Artwork Episode 413: SOUL CARE SUMMER - Andy Crouch, "Create More Than You Consume" 31:33 Episode Artwork Episode 412: SOUL CARE SUMMER - Andy Crouch, "Amusing Ourselves to Death" 30:03 Episode Artwork Episode 411: SOUL CARE SUMMER - Haejin Shim & Mako Fujimura, "The Fractures Filled with Gold" 53:44 Episode Artwork Episode 410: SOUL CARE SUMMER - Dan Allender, "The Story You Haven't Told" 40:05 Episode Artwork Episode 409: SOUL CARE SUMMER - Dan Allender, "None of Us Gets a Pass, Part 1" 27:53 Episode Artwork Episode 408: SOUL CARE SUMMER - Brad Jersak, "The God Who Never Looks Away" 43:22 Episode Artwork Episode 407: SOUL CARE SUMMER - Curt Thompson, "The Look That Sees You" 30:47 Episode Artwork Episode 406: SOUL CARE SUMMER - Curt Thompson, "You are Dirt and Breath" 39:19 Episode Artwork Episode 405: SOUL CARE SUMMER - Chuck DeGroat, "The Nine Faces of Narcissism" 47:45 Episode Artwork Episode 404: Brian Zahnd, "Why Heaven Has Gone Missing from the Church" 42:39 Episode Artwork Episode 403: SOUL CARE SUMMER - Sheila Wray Gregoire, "The Great Sex Rescue" 45:21 Episode Artwork Episode 402: SOUL CARE SUMMER - Aundi Kolber, "Try Softer, Part 2" 32:20 Episode Artwork Episode 401: SOUL CARE SUMMER - Aundi Kolber, "Try Softer, Part 1" 33:05 Episode Artwork Episode 400 - Dr. Gary Chapman, "The Love Language That Matters Most" 26:09 Episode Artwork Episode 399 - Ken Shigematsu, "How To Become Yourself" 52:25 Episode Artwork Episode 398 - Michael John Cusick, "The Temptation of Jesus and Your Attachment" 34:23 Episode Artwork Episode 397 - Geoff Holsclaw, "Your Attachment Style Shapes How You See God" 1:03:45 Episode Artwork Episode 396 - Liz Hall, "Find Meaning In Suffering" 1:01:13 Episode Artwork Episode 395 - Jay Stringer, "How Our Deepest Longings Shape Love, Healing, and Transformation" 1:08:06 Episode Artwork Episode 394 - Brian Lee, "From Broken to Beloved: A Journey through Spiritual Healing" 52:09 Episode Artwork Episode 393 - Safe and Secure: Attachment Styles, Boundaries, and Spiritual Healing 39:16